The Case For A Simpler Tax Code

After studying the personal income tax code for a couple of years now I believe that the U.S. tax code is insanely inefficient, gives benefits to people that don’t need it, and ends costing taxpayers not only money but countless hours.

If you look at the tax code and just look at the deductions it is pretty easy to tell what things are deductions. Nearly everything that is a deduction is only a deduction because the government has made it expensive. Take for instance education costs and medical expenses (which are deductible). You never see deductions for things like cell phones, computers, or areas where the free market is involved. People can deduct interest on their home (which leads to bigger houses than we would otherwise have without the deduction).  The charitable deduction leads to people to give to charity, however as Dan Mitchell points out here that history shows that the deduction itself does not lead people to give more to charity since giving has historically been the same (even before the deduction was put into place). The charitable deduction generally benefits people with high income as they can deduct up to 50% of their (Adjusted Gross income). Also if property is donated to a charity over a certain amount it has to be appraised which requires more forms and paperwork.

What is really sad is that Social Security benefits are taxable. So essentially people are paying taxes Social Security taxes when they work and when they collect their benefits (double taxation).

Currently the tax code is 3.8 million words long (2010). Since 2001 there have been 4,428 changes to the tax law in addition to filling out 893 forms to fill out. The complexity of the tax code can be found in this Forbes article. According to this Laffer Center report the cost of tax compliance is $431.1 billion. I would think both parties would agree this is a waste of both time and money. The biggest problem I see is that the tax code makes it hard for even honest and decent people to figure how to file out their taxes. Many of the tax laws exist to benefit certain people while disadvantaging others. Did you know for instance if you rental out a home less than 14 days per year you don’t have to report it as income. This actually came about because during the Masters Golf tournament and Atlanta summer Olympics politicians and others would rent their homes out to people and didn’t want to have to pay tax on it so they created a tax law saying you didn’t have to. 

What is strange is that let's say you invest in a stock and when you sell the stock it is worth less than you paid for it. This loss can be used to reduce your taxes. It seems troubling/odd that the government is giving investors a benefit for investing unwisely. However, the maximum amount is only $3,000 per year.

 The IRS seems to be proud of answering 68% of calls in 2012 (average wait time was 17 minutes). If a private business took 17 minutes to answer phone calls they would be out of business. Part of the reason why so many people call the IRS is because the tax code is pretty darn complicated.

Many people have an interest in the tax code being complicated. Upon a little research I discovered that there are around 1.2 million accountants (this includes auditors as well). 68,000 professional financial planners, tax accountants, and other professionals that have a direct interest in the complexity of the tax law. Also there are other indirect professions that are related to the tax code such as home relators (mortgage interest deduction), insurance industry, and others.

The opportunity costs is not only 6.1 billion hours for the people that do taxes but the amount of useless knowledge accountants, financial planners, and tax attorneys are required to know adds little value. If we had a flat tax they wouldn't be required to remember so much nonsense and could be free to add value in other ways.